Request More Information     |     Forward to a Colleague     |       Print This Article     |       Print This Issue


A Strategic Approach to
Reducing Bad Debt


By Keith Hearle and Shari Bailey
Verité Healthcare Consulting, LLC



A new era of transparency and accountability has arrived for America's hospitals. The updated IRS Form 990, which all tax-exempt organizations must file beginning in 2009, requires disclosing a wider range of data about charity care policies and costs, community benefit activities, bad debt expense, and executive compensation.

While Form 990 will demand more time and resources for completion, it offers organizations the opportunity to ensure they are minimizing bad debt, appropriately identifying reportable community benefits, and maximizing cash flow. Achieving these objectives requires a strategic approach.

Essential Elements of a Strategic Plan
Every healthcare organization wants to reduce bad debt by optimizing cash collections and reportable charity care. To be successful, healthcare providers must develop a strategic plan for revenue cycle management that includes these essential elements.
  1. Finding third-party sources of payment for self-pay patients, including Medicaid and other governmental sources.


  2. Ensuring that policies governing charity care and collections incorporate best practices and are consistently implemented. Examples of these policies – and much more on meeting the requirements of Form 990 – can be found at the 990 Coalition for Hospitals Web site.


  3. Improving point-of-service and post-service collections from self-pay patients.


  4. Building an operational revenue cycle structure that is well managed with competent and knowledgeable employees, efficient, "patient friendly," and guided by effective policies and procedures for self-pay accounts receivable management.


  5. Ensuring that the accounting process properly recognizes revenue, bad debt expense and charity care. Healthcare Financial Management Association (HFMA) Statement 15 suggests that bad debt is overstated because "healthcare providers inappropriately classify some items as bad debts that were never revenue in the first place." This occurs because they were never truly collectible.


  6. Installing modern technology that supports processes and data analysis needed in today's environment.
Role of Information Technology
While all of these elements are needed to achieve optimal outcomes, effective implementation is achieved with information technology. Technology enables providers to systematize financial assistance policies by incorporating best practices into their workflow and enabling patient access employees to apply them consistently — at the front end of the revenue cycle.

       An emerging best practice is to grant charity care to patients who
         are "medically indigent" because their out-of-pocket healthcare
         expenses exceeded a specified amount of household income
         during the prior 12 months. Future technology will need to track
         patient spending, estimate upcoming patient out-of-pocket
         amounts, and flag patients who qualify for this form of assistance.

       Hospitals can use technology to support documentation
         requirements for charity eligibility — so long as the policies
         incorporate these procedures.

       Technology can help establish fair payment options by
         relying on scoring based on the patient's credit history and record
         of paying medical bills.

       Technology supports operations by providing:

            Real time and batch eligibility on all self-pay patients
            Identifying patients who could be eligible for Medicaid
            Automation of the financial assistance and Medicaid application
              process
            Workflow management
            Consistent application of policy
            Integration of payment processing

       Technology can help ensure that revenue is recognized          appropriately and bad debt is reduced. Technology systems can          also provide the basis for reclassifying bad debt to charity care          retroactively.

Putting Policies into Action
From a strategic viewpoint, technology is not a quick fix. Instead it is a means by which carefully crafted policies and procedures are integrated into daily operations. Providers can create and implement a charity care policy that accurately identifies patients who truly have difficulty paying their bills. With ready access to patient data such as coverage information and ability-to-pay scoring, providers can use IT to make those kinds of determinations early in the process.

In summary, technology can:

       Find eligibility for coverage early in the process

       Support documentation requirements for granting financial
         assistance

       Provide metrics on charity care

       Automate the financial assistance and Medicaid-application
         processes

       Provide data for informed patient discussions regarding
         payment options

       Perform retroactive analysis to justify account reclassification
         from bad debt to charity care

       Support the accounting and revenue recognition process

       Help incorporate best practices into policies and operations

Implementing a strategic plan provides positive operational and financial benefits for everyone — patients and healthcare providers alike.

Keith Hearle, president of Verité Healthcare Consulting, LLC, has more than 20 years of consulting, management, and research experience in the healthcare field. He assisted the National Association of Children's Hospitals, the Catholic Health Association (CHA), and the American Association of Medical Colleges (AAMC) in preparing comments on the draft IRS Form 990 for tax-exempt healthcare organizations, which is based on the CHA accounting framework for community benefit. Verité specializes in healthcare strategy development, financial analysis and decision support, self-pay accounts receivable management, and public policy analysis.

Shari L. Bailey, vice president of Verité Healthcare Consulting, previously served as senior director of Revenue Cycle for Mercy Health Partners of Southwest Ohio. While in that role, she was responsible for access management, self-pay accounts receivable management, centralized scheduling, and insurance verification. Shari has extensive clinical and financial operations management experience in urgent care, occupational medicine centers and a multi-specialty physician practice.


Hospital emergency rooms tell the story of how the uninsured get care. Uninsured patients with chronic diseases often cannot afford regular office visits, maintenance of prescription regimens and other care recommendations. A recent report documents that story. "Eroding Access among Nonelderly U.S. Adults with Chronic Conditions: Ten Years of Change," was published online July 28, 2008, in Health Affairs Journal.

The study finds that access to care by nonelderly, uninsured adults with chronic conditions has declined over the past decade, and the reason is cost of care. By definition, chronic diseases require continuing care to manage symptoms and prevent complications — and to save health dollars.

       One-third of those with chronic conditions had difficulty getting          the care they needed due to cost, and were twice as likely to          either forgo or delay care.

       The uninsured with a newly diagnosed chronic condition are          less likely to follow the recommendation for follow-up care due          to cost, and they end up making more visits to the emergency          department (ED).

Return visits are more costly than regular exams or drugs to treat the chronic condition, and often result in a bad debt burden for the hospital.

While bad debt can be reduced using IT tools to help qualify the uninsured and underinsured for charity care, it can also be reduced by helping these patients get well and stay well. Return visits can be reduced through strategies such as placement with a primary care physician in the community, care coordination, education and monitoring to assist patients in management of chronic diseases, and disease management for the high-risk, high-cost uninsured.

An innovative multi-pronged program from McKesson is designed to help these patients manage their disease and reduce readmissions or return visits to the hospital ED. McKesson's Community Care Advantage improves community wellness, chronic care management and patient satisfaction, and reduces the burden of uncompensated care with services that include:

       Analytics

       Individualized care coordination

       Establishment and reinforcement of a medical home or usual
         source of primary care

       Disease management of high-cost, high risk patients

       24x7 telephonic access to a nurse

Helping the uninsured and underinsured manage their chronic diseases can improve patient outcomes and overall hospital quality scores while reducing uncompensated expenses.






Novant's redesigned patient statements and online billing office ease the billing process, helping to increase self-pay and reduce bad debt.



Wellmont uses a continuous improvement policy informed by business analytics to identify process change, staffing reorganization or technology to improve the revenue cycle.


Enterprise Revenue Management reinvents healthcare revenue management by automating financial processes and connecting key healthcare stakeholders.




5995 Windward Parkway
Alpharetta, GA 30005


Contact Us    |    Feedback    |    Privacy Policy    |    Disclaimer
Copyright © 2008 McKesson Corporation and/or one of its subsidiaries.